Five Star and Senior Star… Again
Oh boy, here we go again. Bill and Bob Thomas have sent another letter to shareholders of Five Star Quality Care, of which they own about 3.4 million shares, or 6.8% of the company. As shareholders, they are glad that management realized that they had some valuable assets, the full value of which is not reflected in the share value. It rarely is. But, as we pointed out a few months ago when Five Star sold a few assets for a big price, and a big gain, with seven properties worth more than the market cap of the entire company, they are also subjecting themselves to a big lease payment liability, which will cut into cash flow. As shareholders, this is not making the Thomas brothers happy.... Read More »Senior Star’s Five Star move
The Thomas Twins of Senior Star certainly had the right idea. Remember, they proposed buying all the owned properties of Five Star Senior Living for about $325 million, which we always assumed was an opening offer. Five Star has now agreed to sell just seven of its assisted living communities with 545 units to its REIT big brother, Senior Housing Properties Trust, in a sale/leaseback transaction. The price of $112.4 million comes to $206,200 per unit, and using that value (which we believe is high for the entire owned portfolio) on the remaining 26 owned properties with 2,666 units results in an additional $549 million in value. Five Star’s market cap, even after the nearly 40% jump in its... Read More »Five Star Says No Deal
As expected, Five Star Quality Care has rejected the offer by an affiliate of Senior Star to purchase the 33 owned senior living communities for $325 million. Basically, the board said the assets are not for sale, and that the company could improve the value of the shares by improving earnings. Unfortunately, just improving earnings does not result in a higher stock value in this market. Just ask management at Capital Senior Living. So if someone will offer more for the owned real estate than what the entire company is worth, based on its current stock price, what would someone pay for the owned real estate and the operating company? That may be a question that Bill and Bob Thomas may try... Read More »Seniors Housing Companies on the Defensive
Oh, what an end of the year. With just three publicly traded seniors housing companies, all three are under some sort of pressure to do something to increase shareholder value. First it was Brookdale Senior Living, then Capital Senior Living and now Five Star Quality Care. The owners of Senior Star have made an unsolicited offer to buy Five Star’s 33 owned communities with more than 3,100 units, with assisted living and memory care representing just over 75% of the total units and independent living the remainder. At a price of $325 million, or just over $100,000 per unit, the value to shareholders comes to more than $5.00 per share net of some mortgage debt. Five Star currently trades... Read More »